Language Learning in Geography Education: Secondary Analysis of a Systematic Literature Review to Identify Further Blind Spots
Abstract
Language is essential for success in geography education. The use of academic and subject-specific language contributes to learning barriers, especially for students with heterogeneous linguistic proficiency and for second language learners. Thus, knowledge of the extent and variety of research on the role of language in geography education is of significance. To date, no systematic overview has been published of respective research fields in geography education as these relate to language at primary (ISCED I), lower secondary (ISCED II), and upper secondary (ISCED III) levels. In order to reveal and address potential blind spots in the research, this study provides a systematic review following the PRISMA scheme to indicate research foci, desiderata, and resulting potentials for future research in the field. The results of a secondary analysis of 38 peer-reviewed publications show diverse countries of origin. Studies in upper secondary schools and with samples including native-speaker students are largely represented, while primary education is barely represented. Research designs were evenly distributed with an emphasis on pre-post-design methods with quasi-experimental designs. Longitudinal studies were not reported.References
Adams A.M., “Utilizing a key word unraveling strategy to improve content comprehension in a high school agriculture earth science class”, Ph.D. Thesis, University of California, Davis, 2004.
Adeyemi S.B. and Cishe E.N., “Effects of cooperative and individualistic learning strategies on students’ map reading and interpretation”, Ghana Journal of Develop-ment Studies, 13, 2, 2016, pp. 154-175.
Akinnaso F., “On the differences between spoken and written language”, Language and Speech, 25, 2, 1982, pp. 97-125.
Aldobaikhi H.A., “Communication, interac-tion and collaboration by female Saudi secondary school students arising through asynchronous e-learning”, Ph.D. Thesis, University of Southampton, Southampton, 2016.
Alford J. and Windeyer A., “Responding to national curriculum goals for English lan-guage learners: Enhancing reading strategies in junior high school content areas”, Journal of Immersion and Content-Based Language Education, 2, 1, 2014, pp. 74-95.
Batini F., Barbisoni G. and Marchetta G., “Shared reading aloud as a tool to improve integration: An experiment in Porta Palazzo (Turin, Italy)”, J-READING (Journal of Research and Didactics in Geography), 1, 2023, pp. 25-39.
Brennan R.L. and Prediger D.J., “Coefficient kappa: Some uses, misuses, and alternatives”, Educational and Psychological Measurement, 41, 3, 1981, pp. 687-699.
Brown B.A., “Discursive identity: Assimi-lation into the culture of science and its implications for minority students”, Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 41, 8, 2004, pp. 810-834.
Brown B.A., “It isn’t no slang that can be said about this stuff’: Language, identity, and appropriating science discourse”, Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 43, 1, 2006, pp. 96-126.
Brown B.A., Donovan B. and Wild A., “Language and cognitive interference: How using complex scientific language limits co-gnitive performance”, Science Education, 103, 4, 2019, pp. 750-769.
Brown B.A. and Ryoo K., “Teaching science as a language: A ‘content-first’ approach to science teaching”, Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 45, 5, 2008, pp. 529-553.
Chafe W. and Danielewicz J., “Properties of spoken and written language”, Academic Press, 16, 1987, pp. 383-407.
Chang C.C., Tsai L.T., Chang C.H., Chang K.C. and Su C.F., “Effects of science reader belief and reading comprehension on high school students’ science learning via mobile devices”, Sustainability, 13, 8, 2021, pp. 1-17.
Chang C.-Y., “Does problem solving = prior knowledge + reasoning skills in earth science? An exploratory study”, Research in Science Education, 40, 2, pp. 103-116.
Cleary A., “A primary teacher’s exploration of the effects of formative assessment on teaching and learning”, Master Thesis, National University of Ireland, Maynooth, 2019.
Council of Europe, Common European framework of reference for languages: Learning, teaching, assessment, Strasbourg, Council of Europe Publishing, 2020.
Creswell J.W., Educational Research: Planning, Conducting, and Evaluating Quantitative Qualitative Research, New Jersey, Pearson, 2019.
Creswell J.W. and Creswell J., Research Design: Qualitative, Quantitative, and Mixed Methods Approaches, Los Angeles, Pearson, 2018.
Cummins J., “The role of primary language development in promoting educational success for language minority students”, in California State Department of Education (Ed.), Schooling and Language Minority Students. A Theoretical Framework, Los Angeles, Dissemination and Assessment Center, 1982, pp. 3-49.
Dal B., “Assessing students’ acquisition of basic geographical knowledge”, International Research in Geographical and Environ-mental Education, 17, 2, 2008, pp. 114-130.
Davies M. and Meissel K., “The use of Quality Talk to increase critical analytical speaking and writing of students in three secondary schools”, British Educational Research Journal, 42, 2, 2016, pp. 342-365.
Engelen E. and Budke A., “Secondary school students’ development of arguments for complex geographical conflicts using the internet”, Education Inquiry, 14, 1, 2023, pp. 85-104.
Falode O.C., Usman H., Ilobeneke S.C., Mohammed H.A., Godwin A.J. and Jimoh M.A., “Improving secondary school geo-graphy students’ positive attitude towards map reading through computer simulation instructional package in Bida, Niger State, Nigeria”, Bulgarian Journal of Science and Education Policy, 10, 1, 2016, pp. 142-155.
Firth R. and Morgan J., “What is the place of radical/critical research in geography education?”, International Research in Geo-graphical and Environmental Education, 19, 2, 2010, pp. 109-113.
Gallagher F. and Leahy A., “From drowned drumlins to pyramid-shaped peaks: Ana-lysing the linguistic landscape of geography to support English language learning in the mainstream classroom”, Irish Educational Studies, 38, 4, 2019, pp. 435-450.
Gay G., “Preparing for culturally responsive teaching”, Journal of Teacher Education, 53, 2, 2002, pp. 106-116.
Gersmehl P., Teaching Geography, New York, The Guilford Press, 2014.
Gogolin I., “Multilingualism: A threat to public education or a resource in public education? – European histories and realities”, European Educational Research Journal, 20, 3, 2021, pp. 297-310.
Gough D. and Thomas J., “Systematic reviews of research in education: Aims, myths and multiple methods”, Review of Education, 4, 1, 2016, pp. 84-102.
Halliday M.A.K., “The notion of ‘context’ in language education”, in Ghadessy M. (Ed.), Text and Context in Functional Linguistics, Amsterdam, John Benjamin Publishing Company, 1999, pp. 1-24.
Heidari N., Feser M.S., Scholten N., Schwippert K. and Sprenger S., “Research on the Role of Language in Geography Education: A Systematic Literature Review”, 2023, https://doi.org/10.3102/2006 164.
Heidari N., Feser M.S., Scholten N., Schwippert K. and Sprenger S., “Language in primary and secondary geography education: A systematic literature review of empirical geography education research”, International Research in Geographical and Environmental Education, 32, 3, 2022, pp. 234-251.
Hinde E.R., Popp S.E.O., Dorn R.I., Ekiss G.O., Mater M., Smith C.B. and Libbee M., “The integration of literacy and geography: The Arizona GeoLiteracy Program’s effect on reading comprehension”, Theory & Research in Social Education, 35, 3, 2007, pp. 343-365.
Holzer M.A., “Building bridges to climate literacy through the development of systems and spatial thinking skills”, Ph.D. Thesis, Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey, New Brunswick, New Jersey, 2016.
Kalinowski E., Gronostaj A. and Vock M., “Effective professional development for teachers to foster students’ academic language proficiency across the curriculum: A systematic review”, AERA Open, 5, 1, 2019, pp. 1-23.
Karasavvidis I., Pieters J.M. and Plomp T., “Investigating how secondary school students learn to solve correlational problems: Quantitative and qualitative discourse approaches to the development of self-regulation”, Learning and Instruction, 10, 3, 2000, pp. 267-292.
Kerlin S.C., McDonald S.P. and Kelly G.J., “Complexity of secondary scientific data sources and students’ argumentative dis-course”, International Journal of Science Education, 32, 9, 2010, pp. 1207-1225.
Kohl K., Willard J.A., Agache A., Bihler L.-M. and Leyendecker B., “Classroom quality, classroom composition, and age at entry: Experiences in early childhood education and care and single and dual language learners’ German vocabulary”, AERA Open, 5, 1, 2019, pp. 1-16.
Ladson-Billings G., “From the achievement gap to the education debt: Understanding achievement in US schools”, Educational Researcher, 35, 7, 2006, pp. 3-12.
Lane R. and Bourke T., “Assessment in geography education: A systematic re-view”, International Research in Geogra-phical and Environmental Education, 28, 1, 2019, pp. 22-36.
Lee S., “Vocabulary and content learning in grade earth science: Effects of vocabulary preteaching, rational cloze task, and reading comprehension task”, The CATESOL Journal, 21, 1, 2010, pp. 75-102.
Lee V.G., “Reading experiences of adolescent boys as they navigate the multiple discourses and social contexts of school, home, and rural community: An ethnographic case study”, Ph.D. Thesis, University of Northern Colorado, Greeley, Colorado, 2006.
Linberg T. and Wenz S.E., “Ausmaß und Verteilung sozioökonomischer und migrationsspezifischer Ungleichheiten im Sprachstand fünfjähriger Kindergartenkinder [Extent and distribution of socioeconomic and migration-specific inequalities in the language level of five-year-old kindergarten children]”, Journal for Educational Research Online, 9, 1, 2017, pp. 77-98.
Lloyd A.M., “Place-based outdoor learning enriching curriculum: A case study in an Australian primary school”, Ph.D. Thesis, Western Sydney University, Sydney, 2016.
McAuliffe M. and Triandafyllidou A., World migration report 2022, Report of International Organization for Migration (IOM), Geneva, UN, 2021.
Morawski M. and Budke A., “Learning with and by language: Bilingual teaching strategies for the monolingual language-aware geogra-phy classroom”, The Geography Teacher, 14, 2, 2017, pp. 48-67.
Nuryanti A., Kaniawati I. and Suwarma I. R., “Junior high school students’ scientific literacy on earth science concept”, Journal of Physics: Conference Series, 1157, 2, 2019.
Nyoni E., Manyike T.V. and Lemme E., “Difficulties in geography teaching and learning in the ESL classroom in Zimba-bwe”, Per Linguam, 35, 2, 2019, pp. 74-87.
Oxley E. and de Cat C., “A systematic review of language and literacy inter-ventions in children and adolescents with English as an additional language (EAL)”, The Language Learning Journal, 49, 3, 2021, pp. 265-287.
Page M.J., McKenzie J.E., Bossuyt P.M., Boutron I., Hoffmann T.C., Mulrow C.D., Shamseer L., Tetzlaff J.M., Akl E.A., Brennan S.E., Chou R., Glanville J., Grimshaw J.M., Hróbjartsson A., Lalu M.M., Li T., Loder E.W., Mayo-Wilson E., McDonald S., McGuinness L.A., Stewart L.A., Thomas J., Tricco A.C., Welch V.A., Whiting P. and Moher D., “The PRISMA 2020 statement: An updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews”, BMJ, 372, 71, 2021, pp. 1-9.
Pallant A., Lee H.-S. and Pryputniewicz S., “How to support secondary school students’ consideration of uncertainty in scientific argument writing: A case study of a high-adventure science curriculum module”, Journal of Geoscience Education, 68, 1, 2020, pp. 8-19.
Paris D., “Culturally sustaining pedagogy: A needed change in stance, terminology, and practice”, Educational Researcher, 41, 3, 2012, pp. 93-97.
Patton M.Q., Qualitative Research & Evaluation Methods: Integrating Theory and Practice, Los Angeles, Sage Publications, 2014.
Pedretti G., “The use of mental rehearsal strategies to develop high school agriculture earth science students’ skills in reading and following laboratory assignment directi-ons”, University of California, Davis, 2009.
Polman J.L. and Pea R.D., “Transformative communication as a cultural tool for guiding inquiry science”, Science Education, 85, 3, 2001, pp. 223-238.
Rampersad A., Shahiba A. and Ali N., “Improving literacy in secondary school geography”, Caribbean Curriculum, 27, 2020, pp. 156-189.
Reich G.A., “Testing historical knowledge: Standards, multiple-choice questions and student reasoning”, Theory and Research in Social Education, 37, 3, 2009, pp. 325-360.
Richter D., Marin F. and Decanini M.M.S., “The sketch maps as a language to analyze geographic reasoning”, Procedia – Social and Behavoral Sciences, 46, 2012, pp. 5183-5186.
Rieder-Bünemann A., “Second language learning”, in Seel N.M. (Ed.), Encyclopedia of the Sciences of Learning, Boston, Springer, 2012, pp. 2980-2983.
Riffel A.D., “An insight into a school’s readiness to implement a CAPS related indigenous knowledge curriculum for meteorological sciences”, Universal Journal of Educational Research, 3, 11, 2015, pp. 906-916.
Rudsberg K. and Öhman J., “The role of knowledge in participatory and pluralistic approaches to ESE”, Environmental Educa-tion Research, 21, 7, 2015, pp. 955-974.
Ruhimat M., Ningrum E. and Wijayanto B., “The implementation of problem based learning toward students’ reasoning ability and geography learning Motivation”, IOP Conference Series-Earth and Environmental Science 1st Upi International Geography Seminar 2017, Bristol, 2018, pp. 1-9.
Schleppegrell M.J., The Language of Schooling: A Functional Linguistics Perspective, New York, Routledge, 2004.
Schostak J. and Schostak J., Radical Re-search: Designing, Developing and Writing Research To Make a Difference, New York, Routledge, 2007.
Seah L.H. and Chan K.K.H., “A case study of a science teacher’s knowledge of students in relation to addressing the language demands of science”, International Journal of Science and Mathematics Education, 19, 2, 2021, pp. 267-287.
See B.H., Gorard S. and Siddiqui N., “Can explicit teaching of knowledge improve reading attainment? An evaluation of the Core Knowledge curriculum”, British Educational Research Journal, 43, 2, 2017, pp. 372-393.
Sejati A.E., Amaluddin L.O., Hidayati D.N., Kasmiati S., Sumarmi and Ruja I.N., “The effect of outdoor study on the geography scientific paper writing ability to construct student character in senior high school”, Advances in Social Science Education and Humanities Research, 100, 2017, pp. 104-118.
Shanahan T. and Shanahan C., “What is disciplinary literacy and why does it matter?”, Topics in Language Disorders, 32, 1, 2012, pp. 7-18.
Słomska-Przech K., Panecki T. and Pokojski W., “Heat maps: Perfect maps for quick reading? Comparing usability of heat maps with different levels of generaliza-tion”, ISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information, 10, 8, 2021, pp. 1-24.
Snow C.E. and Uccelli P., “The challenge of academic language”, in Olson D.R. and Torrance N. (Eds.), The Cambridge Handbook of Literacy, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2009, pp. 112-113.
Sormunen E. and Lehtio L., “Authoring Wikipedia articles as an information literacy assignment: Copy-pasting or expressing new understanding in one’s own words?”, Information Research an International Electronic Journal, 16, 4, 2011, pp. 1-2.
Spires H.A., Kerkhoff S.N., Graham A.C.K., Thompson I. and Lee J.K., “Operationali-zing and validating disciplinary literacy in secondary education”, Reading and Wri-ting, 31, 6, 2018, pp. 1401-1434.
Suwono H., Salmah H. and Tenzer A., “Scientific literacy profile of science and non-science students in senior high schools in Malang”, in Habiddin H., Majid S., Ibnu S., Farida N. and Dasna I.W. (Eds.), Proceedings of 3rd International Conference on Mathematics and Science Education (Malang, 26-28 August), Malang, 2019, pp. 070024-1-070024-6.
Thomas D.B., “Using the multimedia strategies of learner-generated drawing and peer discussion to retain terminology in secondary education science classrooms”, Ph.D. Thesis, University of North Carolina, Charlotte, 2017.
UNESCO Institute for Statistics, Interna-tional standard classification of education: ISCED 2011, Montreal, UNESCO Institute for Statistics, 2012.
Utami W.S., Zain I.M. and Sumarmi S., “Geography literacy can develop Geography skills for high school students: Is it true?”, in Abadi A.M. and Wibawa S.C. (Eds.), Proceedings of IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering (Sura-baya, 22-23 May 2017), 2018, pp. 1-6.
Voss S.M., “The affordances of multimodal texts and their impact on the reading process”, Ph.D. Thesis, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, 2011.
Ward-Washington R.R., “The effectiveness of instruction in using reading comprehension strategies with eleventh-grade social studies students”, Ph.D. Thesis, The University of Mississippi, Mississippi, 2001.
Yoo B.H., Kwak Y. and Park W.M., “Analysis of argumentation structure in students’ writing on socio-scientific issues (SSI): Focusing on the unit of climate change in High School Earth Science I”, Journal of the Korean Earth Science Society, 41, 4, 2020, pp. 405-414.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
The Author assigns to the Nuova Cultura and to Italian Association of Geography Teachers all rights under copyright that can exist in and to the submitted paper. The Author warrants that the paper and images (photos, maps, graphs etc.) are original and that he/she is the Author of the submitted contribution and its parts; in the case of images taken by other publications, the Author must provide a specific authorization and must pay in advance any copyright.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
